The Disengaged Teen: Expert Strategies Every Parent Should Know (April 23, 2026)
Key Takeaways from Authors: Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop:
Why engagement matters
Engagement helps teens build confidence, resilience, curiosity, and ownership over their learning. Understanding your teen is the first step toward helping them become more engaged and can improve both their learning and their well-being. Disengaged Teen co-authors Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop identify four modes of learning that students use to navigate the academic and social demands of high school and beyond.
The Disengaged Teen Book
The Disengaged Teen for Parents
Resister mode
In Resister mode, disengagement is visible. Teens may push back, shut down, avoid work, or reject school altogether. This behavior often signals frustration, discouragement, or disconnection rather than simple defiance.
What to do when your teen is in Resister mode: Jenny and Rebecca suggest that when your teen is in resister mode, treat their behavior as a signal that something isn’t working rather than simple defiance. Stay calm, get curious, and acknowledge what they’re feeling before trying to fix anything. Giving space can help de-escalate the moment and keep things from becoming a power struggle. Avoid lectures, nagging, ultimatums, or jumping straight into solutions, which can intensify resistance instead of resolving it.
Passenger mode
In Passenger mode, teens do what is asked but remain emotionally detached. They may seem fine on the surface, yet they are mainly going through the motions. These students often need help connecting school to their interests, goals, and sense of purpose.
What to do when your teen is in Passenger mode: In passenger mode, your teen may be going through the motions without real engagement, so the goal is to gently reintroduce ownership. The authors advise that you offer small choices, ask for their perspective, and connect tasks to a sense of purpose or relevance. Light check-ins work better than pressure to keep them moving. Avoid over-directing, doing everything for them, or labeling them as lazy, which can reinforce disengagement.
Achiever mode
In Achiever mode, teens perform at a high level but are often driven by pressure rather than genuine engagement. They may look successful while struggling with stress, perfectionism, or fear of failure. Strong outcomes do not always mean a student feels connected to learning.
What to do when your teen is in Achiever mode: When your teen is in achiever mode, they may be highly driven but also at risk of stress or burnout. Jenny and Rebecca suggest that you focus on praising effort rather than just outcomes and encourage balance alongside their goals. It’s important to broaden their sense of success beyond constant performance. Avoid reinforcing perfectionism or treating this as the only “good” mode, as that can increase pressure over time.
Explorer mode
Explorer mode reflects deep, healthy engagement. Teens are motivated by curiosity, purpose, and a desire to learn. This is the mode where students develop the confidence and agency to take ownership of their growth.
What to do when your teen is in Explorer mode: Explorer mode is when your teen is curious and open to trying new things, and it’s important to protect that space. The authors advise that you support their interests without attaching immediate expectations and allow room for trial and error. Keeping some time unstructured helps sustain this kind of growth and motivation. Avoid overscheduling or pushing for quick results, which can shut down their natural curiosity.
Video
The Disengaged Teen: Expert Strategies Every Parent Should Know
In this BigFuture Live, you’ll learn why teens become disengaged and how to better support them at home and in school.
Hear from education experts Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop as they break down the different learning modes teens tend to fall into, including resister, passenger, achiever, and explorer, and how each one shapes motivation, stress, and behavior.
You’ll walk away with practical strategies to communicate more effectively, reduce pressure, and help your teen re-engage in a way that works for them.
Video
Disengaged Teen: Intro
This video introduces student engagement through a personal story from education researcher Jenny Anderson, co-author (with Rebecca Winthrop) of The Disengaged Teen. Reflecting on her child’s experience during COVID-19, Anderson shows how traditional measures like grades can hide true engagement—revealing that some high-achieving students may actually be disengaged, while others flourish when pressure is removed. The video underscores engagement—curiosity, motivation, and agency—as the foundation of real learning, and highlights how difficult it can be for adults to accurately recognize it.
Video
Disengaged Teen: Resister
This video features Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop, co-authors of The Disengaged Teen, introducing the concept of “Resister Mode”—a form of student disengagement where learners push back against school demands. Drawing on research and real-life examples, they explain how resistance is often misunderstood as defiance or laziness, when it can actually signal a mismatch between students’ needs and their learning environment. The video emphasizes that recognizing and addressing Resister Mode is key to re-engaging students by fostering autonomy, relevance, and a stronger sense of purpose in their learning.
Video
Disengaged Teen: Passenger
This video features Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop, co-authors of The Disengaged Teen, exploring “Passenger Mode”—a form of disengagement where students go through the motions of school without genuine interest or ownership of their learning. They explain how these students often appear compliant and successful on the surface, yet lack curiosity, motivation, and a sense of purpose. The video highlights why Passenger Mode can be difficult for educators and parents to detect, and stresses the importance of cultivating agency and deeper engagement to move students from passive participation to active learning.
Video
Disengaged Teen: Achiever
This video features Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop, co-authors of The Disengaged Teen, examining “Achiever Mode”—a form of disengagement where students are highly successful by traditional standards but driven primarily by external validation, such as grades and praise. They explain how these students can appear fully engaged while lacking intrinsic motivation, curiosity, and a genuine love of learning. The video highlights the risks of overperformance without purpose and emphasizes the need to help students develop internal motivation, resilience, and a stronger sense of ownership over their learning.
Video
Disengaged Teen: Explorer
This video features Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop, co-authors of The Disengaged Teen, introducing “Explorer Mode”—the most engaged state of learning, where students are driven by curiosity, purpose, and a desire to understand the world around them. They describe how Explorer Mode reflects deep, intrinsic motivation, with students taking ownership of their learning and embracing challenges as opportunities to grow. The video emphasizes that fostering this mode requires supportive environments that prioritize autonomy, relevance, and meaningful learning over performance alone.
Video
Disengaged Teen: Healthier Approach
This video features Jenny Anderson and Rebecca Winthrop, co-authors of The Disengaged Teen, outlining a healthier approach to supporting student engagement across different learning modes. They emphasize the importance of shifting away from a narrow focus on performance and toward nurturing curiosity, autonomy, and purpose. Drawing on their research, they offer strategies for helping students move out of disengaged states—like Resister, Passenger, and Achiever Modes—into Explorer Mode, where learning is meaningful and self-driven. The video highlights the role of adults in creating environments that foster trust, relevance, and intrinsic motivation.
Download